is not surprising that the U.S. has mad cow disease given our flaunting
of World Health Organization recommendations. What is surprising, however,
is that we actually found a case given the inadequacy of our surveillance
program, a level of testing that Nobel laureate Stanley Prusiner, probably
the world's leading expert on these diseases, calls simply "appalling."
....... Europe and Japan follow World Health
Organization guidelines and test every downer cow for mad cow disease;
the U.S. has tested less than 2% of downers over the last decade. Most
of the U.S. downer cows, too sick or injured to even walk, end up on our
dinner plates. In Canada, authorities were able to reassure the public
that at least the downer cow they discovered infected with BSE--Bovine
Spongiform Encephalopathy, or mad cow disease--was excluded from the human
food chain and only rendered into animal feed. U.S. officials don't seem
to be able to offer the same reassurance, as the mad cow we discovered
may very well have been ground into hamburger.
then, can the USDA and the beef industry insist that the American beef
supply is still safe? They argue that the infectious prions that cause
the disease are only found in the brain and nervous tissue, not the muscles,
not the meat. For example, on NBC's Today, USDA Secretary Veneman insisted
"the fact of the matter is that all scientific evidence would show,
based upon what we know about this disease, that muscle cuts -- that is,
the meat of the animal itself -- should not cause any risk to human health.
" The National Cattlemen's Beef Association echoed "Consumers
should continue to eat beef with confidence. All scientific studies show
that the BSE infectious agent has never been found in beef muscle meat
or milk and U.S. beef remains safe to eat. "
can be viewed as misleading and irresponsible on two counts. First, American
do eat bovine central nervous system tissue. The United States General
Accounting Office (GAO) is the investigative watchdog arm of Congress.
In 2002, the GAO released their report on the weaknesses present in the
U.S. defense against mad cow disease. Quoting from thatcongressional report,
"In terms of the public health risk, consumers do not always know
when foods and other products they use may contain central nervous system
tissue... Many edible products, such as beef stock, beef extract, and
beef flavoring, are frequently made by boiling the skeletal remains (including
the vertebral column) of the carcass..."
....... According to the consumer advocacy
organization Center for Science in the Public Interest, spinal cord contamination
may also be found in U.S. hot dogs, hamburgers, pizza toppings, and taco
fillings In fact, a 2002 USDA survey showed that approximately 35 percent
of high risk meat products tested positive for central nervous system
.......The GAO report continues: "In
light of the experiences in Japan and other countries that were thought
to be BSE free, we believe that it would be prudent for USDA to consider
taking some action to inform consumers when products may contain central
nervous system or other tissue that could pose a risk if taken from a
BSE-infected animal. This effort would allow American consumers to make
more informed choices about the products they consume." The USDA,
however, did not follow those recommendations, deciding such foods need
not be labeled. Even if Americans just stick to steak, they may not be
shielded from risk. The "T" in a T-bone steak is a vertebra
from the animal's spinal column, and as such may contain a section of
the actual spinal cord.
....... Other potentially contaminated cuts
include porterhouse, standing rib roast, prime rib with bone, bone-in
rib steak, and (if they contain bone) chuck blade roast and loin. These
cuts may include spinal cord tissue and/or so-called dorsal root ganglia,
swellings of nerve roots coming into the meat from the spinal cord which
have been proven to be infectious as well. This concern has led the FDA
to consider banning the incorporation of "plate waste" from
restaurants into cattle feed. The American Feed Industry Association defends
the current exemption of plate scrapings from the 1997 feed regulations:
"How can you tell the consumer, 'Hey, you've just eaten a T-bone
steak and it's fine for you, but you can't feed it to animals'? "
.......Even boneless cuts may not be risk-free,
though. In the slaughterhouse, the bovine carcass is typically split in
half down the middle with a band saw, sawing right through the spinal
column. This has been shown to aerosolize the spinal cord and contaminate
the surrounding meat. A study in Europe found contamination with spinal
cord material on 100% of the split carcasses examined. Similar contamination
of meat derived from cattle cheeks can occur from brain tissue, if the
cheek meat is not removed before the skull is fragmented or split.
....... The World Health Organization has
pointed out that American beef can be contaminated with brain and spinal
cord tissue in another way as well. Except for Islamic halal and Jewish
kosher slaughter (which involve slitting the cow's throat while the animal
is still conscious), cattle slaughtered in the United States are first
stunned unconscious with an impact to the head before being bled to death.
Medical science has known for over 60 years that people suffering head
trauma can end up with bits of brain embolized into their bloodstream;
so Texas A&M researchers wondered if fragments of brain could be found
within the bodies of cattle stunned for slaughter. They checked and reportedly
exclaimed, "Oh, boy did we find it." They even found a 14 cm
piece of brain in one cow's lung. They concluded, "It is likely that
prion proteins are found throughout the bodies of animals stunned for
slaughter." There are different types of stunning devices, however,
which likely have different levels of risk associated with them.
.......The Texas A&M study was published
in 1996 using the prevailing method at the time, pneumatic-powered air
injection stunning. The device is placed in the middle of the animal's
forehead and fired, shooting a 4 inch bolt through the skull and injecting
compressed air into the cranial vault which scrambles the brain tissue.
The high pressure air not only "produces a smearing of the head of
the animal with liquefied brain," but has been shown over and over
to blow brain back into the circulatory system, scattering whole plugs
of brain into a number of organ, and smaller brain bits likely into the
muscle meat as well Although this method
of stunning has been used in the United States for over 20 years, the
meat industry, to their credit, has been phasing out these particularly
risky air injection-type stunners. The Deputy Director of Public Citizen
argues that this industry initiative should be given the force of federal
regulation and banned, as they have been throughout Europe.
.......The stunning devices that remain in
widespread use drive similar bolts through the skull of the animal, but
without air injection. Operators then may or may not pith the animals
by sticking a rod into the stun hole to further agitate the deeper brain
structures to reduce or eliminate reflex kicking during shackling of the
hind limbs. Even without pithing, which has been shown to be risky, these
stunners currently in use in the U.S. today may still force brain into
the bloodstream of some of these animals.
.......In one experiment, for example, researchers
applied a marker onto the stunner bolt. The marker was later detected
within the muscle meat of the stunned animal. They conclude: "This
study demonstrates that material present in... the CNS of cattle during
commercial captive bolt stunning may become widely dispersed across the
many animate and inanimate elements of the slaughter-dressing environment
and within derived carcasses including meat entering the human food chain."
Even non-penetrative "mushroom-headed" stunners which just rely
on concussive force to the skull to render the animal unconscious may
not be risk free. People in automobile accidents with non-invasive head
trauma can still end up with brain embolization, and these bolts move
at over 200 miles per hour. The researchers at Texas A&M conclude,
"Reason dictates that any method of stunning to the head will result
in the likelihood of brain emboli in the lungs or, indeed, other parts
of the body." And, finally, even if consumers of American beef just
stick to boneless cuts from ritually slaughtered animals who just happen
to have had their spinal columns safely removed, the muscle meat itself
may be infected with prions. It is unconscionable that the USDA and the
beef industry continue to insist that the deadly prions aren't found in
muscle meat. In 2002,Stanley Prusiner, the scientist who won the Nobel
Prize in Medicine for his discovery of prions, proved in mice, at least,
that muscle cells themselves were capable of forming prions. He describes
the levels of prions in muscle as "quite high," and describes
the studies relied upon by the Cattlemen's Association as "extraordinarily
inadequate." Follow-up studies in Germany published May, 2003 confirm
Prusiner's findings, showing that an animal who is orally infected may
indeed end up with prions contaminating muscles throughout their body.
And just last month, published in the New England Journal of Medicine,
Swiss scientists found prions in the muscles of human CJD victims on autopsy.
Eight out of the 32 muscle samples turned up positive for the deadly prions.
.......The discovery of a case of mad cow
disease in the U.S. highlights how ineffective current safeguards are
in North America. The explosive spread of mad cow disease in Europe has
been blamed on the cannibalistic practice of feeding slaughterhouse waste
to livestock. Both Canada and the United States banned the feeding of
the muscles and bones of most animals to cows and sheep back in 1997,
but unlike Europe left gaping loopholes in the law. For example, blood
is currently exempted from the Canadian and the U.S. feed bans. You can
still feed calves cow's blood collected at the slaughterhouse. In modern
factory farming practice calves may be removed from their mothers immediately
after birth, so the calves are fed milk replacer, which is often supplemented
with protein rich cow serum. Weaned calves and young pigs also may have
cattle blood sprayed directly on their feed to save money on feed costs.
For more information on this and other risky agriculture practices please
.......And the Canadian and U.S. feed
bans also allows the feeding of pigs and horses to cows. Cattle remains
can be rendered down and fed to pigs, for example, and then the pig remains
can be fed back to cattle. Or rendered cattle remains can be fed to
chickens and then the chicken litter, or manure, can be legally fed back
to the cows. So the fact that according to the USDA the most infectious
tissues of the U.S. mad cow case, the brain, spinal cord, and intestines,
"were removed from this animal and sent to rendering" is not
.......D. Carleton Gajdusek was also awarded
the Nobel Prize in Medicine for his work on mad cow-like diseases.
He was quoted on Dateline NBC as saying, "it's got to be in the pigs
as well as the cattle. It's got to be passing through the chickens."
Dr. Paul Brown, medical director for the US Public Health Service, believes
that pigs and poultry could indeed be harboring mad cow disease and passing
it on to humans, adding that pigs are especially sensitive to the disease.
"It's speculation," he says, "but I am perfectly serious."
The 2002 General Accounting Office report concluded: "BSE may be
silently incubating somewhere in the United States. If that is the case,
then FDA 's failure to enforce the feed ban may already have placed U.S.
herds and, in turn, the human food supply at risk. FDA has no clear enforcement
strategy for dealing with firms that do not obey the feed ban... Moreover,
FDA has been using inaccurate, incomplete, and unreliable data to track
and oversee feed ban compliance." The report can be downloaded
these shortcomings, Secretary Veneman and Washington's governor both assured
the public that they were still having beef for Christmas, reminiscent
of the 1990 fiasco in which the British agriculture minister appeared
on TV urging his 4-year-old daughter to eat a hamburger. Four years
later, young people in Britain were dying from an invariably fatal neurogenerative
disease called variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease--the human equivalent
of mad cow disease--which they contracted through the consumption of infected
beef. With an incubation period up to decades long, no one knows how
high the final human death toll will be.
slaughtered in the United States are first stunned unconscious with an impact
to the head before being bled to death. Medical science has known for over
60 years that people suffering head trauma can end up with bits of brain
embolized into their bloodstream; so Texas A&M researchers wondered
if fragments of brain could be found within the bodies of cattle stunned
for slaughter. They checked and reportedly exclaimed, "Oh, boy did
we find it." They even found a 14 cm piece of brain in one cow's lung.
They concluded, "It is likely that prion proteins are found throughout
the bodies of animals stunned for slaughter."